Методологія

Дослідження

Показники

Існують наступні індикатори, за якими можна визначати ефективність міста.

КPMG виділяє 4 способи:

image
  1. The cities of Sus model development

image

2. The Green City Index is a tool to help cities compare their environmental performance.

image

3. IESE Cities in Motion Index -

It examines cities through 10 ‘dimensions’: governance, urban planning, public management, technology, the environment, international outreach, social cohesion, mobility and transportation, human capital and the economy. The aim is to create knowledge and develop valuable ideas and innovative tools that can generate smarter cities and promote change at the local level

image

4. GNH Index - ‘gross national happiness’ (GNH)

image

image

image

image

Additionally

image

image

image

image

image

image

image

image

Further development for indicators supporting city intelligence is listed in ISO 37122 which has also been identically adopted as SNI ISO 37122: 2019. In this standard set indicators used to determine the assessment of the performance results of smart cities. The scope of this standard is to determine and define the meanings and limitations also the methods for a group of smart city indicators and parameters. Together with SNI ISO 37120 and ISO 37123, this standard provides a set of various indicators to calculate progress toward smart cities. (Fig.2). To evaluate the maturity and performance of smart cities, SNI ISO 37122: 2019 has been determined (Table 2). As the tool is developed, indicators are very important to establish. Often the first step in doing part is related to relevant indicators using prescribed selection methods, for example, literature discussion, expert selection, and stakeholder discussions. The indicators specified in the SNI ISO 37122: 20119 are 20 sectors and 81 indicators. Cities who wish to implement this document to assess the intelligence performance of their city must report each indicator by the requirements stated in the document. Of the 20 regulated sectors, the transportation and energy sector have a greater number of indicators than the other sectors, so for this sector, more resources will be needed in its implementation. ISO 37123 as the third indicator is in the process of being compiled. The principle of sustainability is a guide in the development of this standard.

image

image

image